Direct mail copy that sells

Why didn’t my mailing sell?

That’s the most common wailing from a marketer who sat all day waiting for the postman to dump a huge bag of orders on the desk … and then, checking the mail, found just three pieces – two bills and somebody else’s offer.

Direct mail failure can stem from a number of sources, ranging from a poor offer to sending the mailing to the wrong names. But it also can result from poor copy.

Direct mail copy that sells has to cleave to the most important component any copywriter ever revered … or ignored — The Clarity Commandment:
When you choose words and phrases for a message intended to be force-communication, clarity is paramount. Don’t let any other component of the communications mix interfere with it.

So, clarity is in first place. What other elements does effective direct mail copy have to include?

The Five Great Motivators

Your copy should drape itself around one of the five Great Motivators that produce response in the first decade of the 21st century:

  • Fear
  • Exclusivity
  • Greed
  • Guilt
  • Need for approval

If you’re especially adept, you can tie one of the two ancillary (supporting) motivators to one of the great ones:

  • Convenience
  • Pleasure

Describing without motivating isn’t salesmanship. And an effective direct mail copywriter is, above all, a salesperson. Description doesn’t require a fraction of the talent that salesmanship requires. That’s why, in a marketing organization, sales copywriters earn three or four times the money a technical writer makes.

Inject benefit.

Good copy always suggests a potent benefit for the reader. Ask yourself, as you write: "Why should the reader buy this?" The answer to that question has to be paramount in your copy, second only to The Clarity Commandment.

And don’t mistake feature for benefit. So the automobile has overhead cams? So what? What’s the benefit of overhead cams? So the computer software uses only 3mb of memory? So what? What’s the benefit of that? If you can’t think of a benefit, for heaven’s sake choose another element that does represent a buyer-benefit.

Use colorful words

The weaker your rhetoric, the weaker your selling argument. If you were a major league baseball pitcher, you wouldn’t lob the ball to the batter underhanded. You’d smoke it in there. Do that with your copy.

So you might say acquire instead of buy because acquire places emphasis on ownership instead of spending money. You might use when you… instead of if you… because when assumes response. You’re in command of the message. Make it seem important.

Speaking of “important”…

Don’t hit-and-run. Don’t claim something is “important” and then not justify your claim. Offer ostensible proof of any claim you make.

Proof can be testimonials, statistics (warning: statistics can be boring), photographic evidence, any number of means. Please don’t use asterisks, ever. They may provide proof but they aren’t good copywriting technique. Not ever.

Read your copy after you’ve written it. Better yet, have an impartial outsider read it… and give you an impartial opinion. If your copy is so ego-driven that you feel any changes will be an attack on your child, you’re in the wrong profession.

Back to Resource Center