The anatomy of a good direct mail piece

What determines whether your direct mail has power? What determines whether your direct mail piece has consummate salesmanship? What determines whether your direct mail piece can compete with the many others clamoring for the recipient’s attention?

A good direct mail piece has three elements: exhortation, description, and easy means of response. Does your mailing have those elements?

Careful, now. Don’t get confused, and in the process confuse those who get your mailing. Follow these simple rules and you’ll wind up with a “good” direct mail piece:

The letter exhorts.
Use the letter, not the brochure, to exhort. The letter is the selling element. It should open with benefit, explain the benefit, justify the benefit, warn the reader of what he or she will lose by not taking advantage of the benefit and – several times within the text – tell the reader how to collect the benefit (repeating a toll-free number is the easiest).

How long should the letter be? That question parallels, “How big is a house?” No one-piece answer exists. The letter should be long enough to sell. That might be one page, two pages, four pages, or even longer. Just don’t overwrite. And don’t squeeze because you’ve decided the letter has to fit onto one page, no matter what.

The brochure describes.
Reader tests show that although the typical recipient reads the letter first, the brochure determines whether the claims made in the letter are valid. Does your brochure accomplish that?

You don’t need lavish photography, full color, or enamel paper. You do need clarity. Sometimes inclusion of a “Question-and-answer” column in the brochure de-fangs the inevitable skepticism. Clarity is paramount, and it’s the job of the brochure to supply that element. Be sure your brochure recapitulates the means of responding, because elements of a mailing can become separated.

The response device makes response easy.
The response device, or order form or coupon or certificate or whatever you call it, should repeat the offer and the benefits. When the recipient is at this point, don’t lose him or her through uncertainty or failure to pump up the buying impulse.

Response should be as easy as you can structure. If you ask for a ton of information, be prepared to see response drop. Get the necessary information, of course, but don’t overdo it. You can always get ancillary information in a follow-up congratulatory call or written communication.

Have you included a business reply envelope? Even though you’re encouraging phone or online response, you know that the older your target is, the more likely it is that the individual will prefer responding by mail. If you don’t supply the envelope, you haven’t made ordering as easy as it could be.

The envelope has to be opened.
Don’t forget the envelope carrying your message. The carrier envelope has a single purpose, other than preventing its contents from spilling out onto the street: to get itself opened.

Sometimes saying nothing on the envelope maximizes response. Sometimes a provocative message maximizes response. Which is proper for your mailing? Ask yourself: If I were getting this instead of sending it, would I open it?

That’s all there is to it. Now, get your list, prepare your mailing, and make some money.

Back to Resource Center